Skip to main content

Pensions Rip-Off Reduced

Pensioner

The introduction of pensions freedom in April 2015 abolished the compulsory purchase on an annuity, and members of defined contribution pension schemes over the age of 55 can now cash in their pensions pot early and use the money in whatever way they wish. However, some schemes levy substantial charges for an early exit.

Early exit charges were common on pensions started in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, and can be as high as 30%, although charges of 2% to 5% are more typical. Such charges are substantially more than the cost to the supplier of an early exit, and present a barrier to the exercise of pension freedom. They are also a barrier which prevents members from transferring their pension pot to another scheme. Therefore this cap is a welcome move which limits the extent to which defined contribution schemes can rip off their customers.

This cap on early exit fees only applies to contract-based defined contribution schemes, and does not apply to trust-based defined contribution schemes who are regulated by the Pensions Regulator (tPR), not the FCA. However tPR intends to impose a similar cap on the early exit fees of trust-based defined contribution schemes as from October 2017. From April 2017 there will also be a 0% cap on early exit fees for new contract-based defined contribution schemes.

While cashing in their pension pot will become more attractive to those currently facing a large early exit fee, members should exercise caution. The value of any pension that is cashed-in is added to the member’s income that year, and this can easily lead to a substantial income tax charge.

By Professor Charles Sutcliffe

Professor Charles Sutcliffe

Professor of Finance
Published 31 March 2017

You might also like

New Book: Corporate Governance: Theory and Practice

23 January 2012
Capitalism is high on the political agenda. Like coffee it seems to come in a bewildering number of varieties. Some politicians like it "responsible" others "moral" and still others "popular". While some argue that it is time for shareholders to wield real power, others feel that that certain shareholders, notably hedge funds should sit on their hands, at least if they have bought shares after a takeover has been announced. Out on the streets the tents of the "occupy" protectors may be under threat but many are sympathetic to the view that bankers and board members have been rewarded for taking too many risks with other people's money.
Press releases

On the odds of no-deal Brexit

3 July 2019
Dr Ioannis Oikonomou discusses the latest story on the Brexit leadership, behavioural biases and the repetition of history.
Business News

PhD student receives Best Paper Award at recent conference

30 May 2012
The ICMA Centre is very proud to congratulate PhD student Yingying Wu on her receipt of a Best Paper Award at the 19th Global Finance Conference, taking place at DePaul University in Chicago on May 23-25, 2012. The prize was awarded for the paper “Commodity Futures Prices: More Evidence on Forecast Power, Risk Premia and the Theory of Storage” (co-authored with Chris Brooks and Marcel Prokopczuk).
Research news