Skip to main content

Indebted students won't benefit from interest rate changes to their loans

Blue pig

It is suggested that the Government are looking at reducing the interest rate charged on the debt accrued by students at Universities (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/09/09/tories-plot-slash-student-loan-rates-attempt-court-young-voters). This is specifically the loan element that covers the Undergraduate Fee for home and EU students. Whilst this interest rate (6.1%) is high when compared to other long-term loan products such as mortgages (best buys currently are anything between 1.5 and 3% per annum depending on deposit size) and could be revised downwards for market parity - it is actually a smoke screen from the actual repayment reality for students and demonstrates either a deliberate or misconceived understanding of loan financing.

As has been modelled recently, a small number of students will pay their fee loan off in full (within 30 years) leaving approx 77.4% of all graduates who will have some of the debt written off. For higher earning graduates, the reduction in interest rate is indeed helpful. However for the lowest earning group (which make up 40% of graduates) the interest rate charged will make absolutely no difference. Why is this?

The repayment scheme introduced by the government charges 9% of income (a fee) via PAYE over a repayment threshold (currently £21,000 per annum). So with this in mind, a student earning £30,000 will pay 9% of £9000 or £810 per year (£67.50 per month). The student will continue to pay for 30 years or until the debt is paid off, whichever comes first. After 30 years it is written off.

For simplicity, if the student continues to earn £30,000 for 30 years and the fee and threshold stay the same, then they will have paid £24,300 towards the debt which is then forgiven (the average repayment is currently estimated to be £48,600). The total debt for the fees alone would be at least £27,000 at the time of the fees being paid and will have then compounded over time at 6.1% per annum which equates to an increase of an additional £5000 during the 3 year study period alone. It really isn’t worth worrying about or calculating the total amount of debt that will be accrued over the 30 years for these students as it does not matter to them; they know what they have to pay.

So the current discussion by the government to change the interest rate on the debt has no effect on the bulk of students. They will pay the same - as a reduced interest rate will still mean that whilst the total debt will decrease, the student in my example will have to pay exactly the same amount i.e. the fee on any earnings above the threshold.

The only thing which would make a difference to the majority of students is a reduction in the fee payable on the loan, or an increase in the threshold - but neither of these options seem to be under discussion.

Data in the above blog taken from:https://www.ifs.org.uk/uploads/publications/bns/BN211.pdf (accessed 11/9/2017) which clearly details the current position of University finances based on the student fee regime.

Professor Adrian Bell

Associate Pro-Vice-Chancellor Research (Prosperity and Resilience)
Published 11 September 2017

You might also like

Medieval Soldiers online at the ICMA Centre!

4 November 2009
For a brief moment on Tuesday 21st July, the online database of medieval soldiers (http://www.medievalsoldier.org/) hosted at the ICMA Centre, was the news! This database of soldiers serving the English crown between 1369-1454 and including the names of men-at-arms and archers who served at famous battles such as Agincourt in 1415, made the front page of the BBC website, was the most shared site on BBC news online, and interviews were given to BBC Radio Four and 5Live, local radio and even the national radio broadcaster in Canada. Some 250,000 service records are now available to freely search and the database recorded some 125,000 hits on Tuesday alone. The database has gone from strength to strength and this publicity has made the online database extremely popular, and it has now registered 3.5 million hits in just three months - demonstrating the interest of our research to the public at large.

Research success for ICMA Centre lecturer

9 October 2012
The ICMA Centre’s Dr Ioannis Oikonomou has reason to look fondly on 2012 as he has experienced two significant academic successes in recent months, which are bringing wider recognition across Europe to the research he is undertaking.
Press releases Research news

Henley Challenge 2014

20 February 2014
The Henley Challenge is an annual competition open to all students across Henley Business School, who are studying in the UK, which encourages the use of knowledge, skill and creativity. The challenge for students this year was to choose a business area studied at Henley to focus on and present to an audience of peers and academics their answer to the question: