Skip to main content

Alcohol, tobacco, and gambling: Do “sin stocks” really outperform other publically listed companies? – Award winning paper by ICMA Centre academics

Award winning research “The Price of Sin Aversion” by ICMA Centre Associate Professor of Finance Andreas Hoepner and co-author Hampus Adamsson has hit the headlines this week, with the Financial Times featuring an article about it in their paper on Monday.

Hoepner and Adamsson’s paper brought to question the idea that “sin stocks” like alcohol, tobacco, and gambling outperformed other publically listed companies, as was originally documented in a previous piece of research by Hong & Kacperczyk (2009).

In the new paper, the academics reported that in previous studies there was a failure to address the company size when approaching “sin stocks”, and that smaller companies tended to outperform larger equivalents in the same industry.

When looking at portfolios that were value-weighted, the academics found “the alcohol, tobacco and sin portfolios do not exhibit any significant outperformance”. In the case of gambling portfolios, there was even a notable underperformance.

As well as being featured in the Financial Times, the research was also awarded “best quantitative paper” at a conference hosted by UN-backed group Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI), which also saw ICMA Centre PhD student Lisa Schopohl win “best student paper”.

One of the paper’s authors, Andreas Hoepner commented: “Investment committee members always have a view on environmental, social and governance (ESG) metrics and some might be sceptical about it. In the past, they might have referred to the sin stock studies — and now they have this study. We are certainly the first voice to say that, statistically, sin stocks do not outperform.”

When asked what impact the paper could have on investors, he said that he hoped it would “increase investor’s confidence that integrating ESG metrics is not harmful.”

Read the full article on the Financial Times here: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/1abc89b4-58a6-11e5-a28b-50226830d644.html#axzz3lhtMiTlt

Download the full paper here: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2659098

Dr Andreas G. F. Hoepner

Visiting Professor
Published 15 September 2015
Topics:
Research news

You might also like

World Book Day: Sharing academic stories

6 March 2019
Book: Raising Venture Capital Finance in Europe

Enhance your skills with the new Advanced Diploma in Investment Compliance

30 April 2010
Investment Compliance The ICMA Centre has a well established expertise in Investment Compliance. We have long recognised and advocated the importance of robust regulatory and compliance policies in financial institutions. This and the level of demand by banks and finance houses for well-trained compliance professionals has led to the Centre running a suite of regulation and compliance executive education programmes both in the UK and around the world. Our corporate clients in the UK include many of major banks such as Deutsche, JPMorgan, Morgan Stanley and Commerzbank. Overseas we have worked with several Central Banks including Serbia and Montenegro, Dubai and Egypt, as well as large corporates in Spain and the Nordic region.

Video: Dante's Inferno and Finance in the middle ages

17 October 2016
"Today you might lose your knighthood, but in the middle ages you'd end up in hell"